Alex Verkhovsky b70486b9bd fix(review): gate routing on explicit review requests (#2716)
* fix(review): gate routing on explicit review requests

bmad-review's description matched any review-like phrasing, so coding
agents entered the review workflow for requests that never asked for
one — install commands, git operations, summary requests, build
handovers, and questions, including a question about the review skill
itself. A week of Codex session logs showed every invocation but one
was unintentional.

Rewrite the description around an explicit ask:

- Trigger only when the user asks to review a diff, a pull request,
  or an artifact — code or documents — and actually says "review".
- Acting on feedback from an earlier review is a change, not a review.
- Never volunteer, including on the agent's own just-made edits.

Validated with a 32-case routing eval, each case judged in an
isolated context, on two agent platforms; ten cases come from the
real over-trigger transcripts. The final wording scores 30/30 on
both platforms; an earlier draft's 29/30 drove the artifact clause
to name code explicitly.

* fix(review): count forwarded skill directives as review asks

Review-bot finding, confirmed by an isolated routing probe: with the
gate reading "when, and only when, the user asks", a literal reader
refuses the documented skill:bmad-review directive form that bmad-prd
and bmad-retrospective use to forward reviews.

Equate the directive with the ask instead of adding a second gate:
an explicit skill:bmad-review directive from another skill counts as
that ask.

The forwarded-directive scenario joins the routing eval as a scored
case; the full 33-case run scores 31/31 (two unscored probes), with
no previously excluded case loosened.
2026-08-12 13:17:37 -07:00
2026-01-07 18:18:12 +08:00
2026-08-10 17:49:08 +00:00

BMad Method

Agile Ai Driven Development — turn an idea or change request into working software without giving up the thinking.

Ai Driven Development (AiDD) covers the whole effort, not only the code: what to build, how it holds together, and how it changes as you learn. BMad Method is the agile way to do it — decisions stay explicit, context carries forward, and the process sizes itself to the work. Small changes go straight to build. Complex work gets the depth it needs. The same method covers a weekend prototype and a system with years of history behind it.

The BMad delivery loop: a vague notion starts at Clarify, a big clear idea at Plan, and a small change at Build and verify; Learn and adjust loops back to Plan

Start anywhere. Use BMad end to end, or carry its briefs, specifications, and architecture into your existing delivery workflow.

Start Building

Prerequisites: Node.js 20.12+, Python 3.10+, and uv

npx bmad-method install

Open your project in your AI coding tool, invoke bmad-build with what you want to change, and keep making the decisions that matter. Run bmad-help whenever you want guidance on what comes next or what is optional.

Build your first project with BMad →

Add BMad to an existing codebase →

BMad is free and open source, with no paywalled workflows or gated community. For prerelease builds, CI/CD, configuration overrides, and non-interactive setup, see the installation guide.

Why BMad?

Coding assistants are effective at implementation, but they often turn unstated assumptions into code. BMad keeps you in control while its agents and workflows make the important decisions explicit and preserve them as context for the work that follows.

  • Right-sized process — Go directly to implementation for clear changes or add deeper planning for larger initiatives.
  • New or existing code — Start from nothing, or establish verified context on a codebase you inherited and work from what is actually there.
  • Durable context — Carry product and technical decisions forward instead of re-explaining them in every chat.
  • Specialized perspectives — Bring in product, architecture, UX, development, and testing expertise when it helps.
  • Guided collaboration — Use structured workflows and multiple-agent discussions without handing over judgment.
  • One delivery path — Move from early thinking through reviewed implementation, correction, and learning.

See how the workflows fit together →

BMad Ecosystem

Install the core method or add official modules for specialized work.

Module Purpose
BMad Method Plan and deliver software, from new prototypes to established codebases
BMad Builder Skill, workflow, and agent builder
BMad Creative Intelligence Suite Creative thinking partners for innovation, design thinking, and storytelling
BMad Test Architect Enterprise testing add-on for BMad Method
BMad Loop Builds, verifies, and retros a whole epic unattended
BMad Game Dev Studio Ideate, design, and build games in any framework, including Unity, Unreal, Godot, and Phaser

Plan on the Web

Web bundles package selected BMad workflows as Google Gemini Gems and ChatGPT Custom GPTs. Use them for planning in your existing web subscription, then bring the resulting artifacts into your AI coding tool for implementation.

Documentation

Roadmap

See what is in progress and what is planned on the public roadmap.

Community

Support and Contributing

BMad is free for everyone and always will be. Star the repository, buy me a coffee, or email contact@bmadcode.com for corporate sponsorship.

Contributions are welcome. Read CONTRIBUTING.md before opening a pull request.

License

MIT License — see LICENSE for details.

BMad and BMAD-METHOD are trademarks of BMad Code, LLC. See TRADEMARK.md for details.

Contributors

See CONTRIBUTORS.md for contributor information.

Version License: MIT Discord

S
Description
Breakthrough Method for Agile Ai Driven Development
Readme MIT 126 MiB
Languages
JavaScript 59%
Python 22%
HTML 16.7%
CSS 1.1%
Shell 0.7%
Other 0.4%